Thursday, August 16

New Aladdin, Same Racism

Google+ Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr +

For most of my life, I saw myself akin to the characters in Disney’s Aladdin. I would dress up as Jasmine for primary school dress up days, and even until college thought of my own culture reflected in the imagery and cultural symbolism of Aladdin. As people of color our ethnicities and racial identities are given little room, so we are often willing to settle for infantilizing, stereotypical depictions of ourselves onscreen.

Aladdin, a movie that is super orientalist, was paradoxically important for South Asian, Arab, and Muslim kids because it’s one of the few movies that addresses the fact that our cultures existed, by not specifically identifying them. I had, for example, an uncle named Jaffer, and so to see a movie character with the same name (pronounced shockingly incorrectly), I was still excited by the prospect of familiarity. It didn’t matter to me that this character was an evil one—I was grateful to have been thought of at all.

Yup. Those are actual lyrics from the title song “Arabian Nights.”

There are numerous accounts of the orientalist nature of Aladdin, where people like me, who may have once thought of this film as one of connection, now see it as a racist interpretation of one’s own people. Worse, though, is the fact that it does not matter what Muslims, Arabs, South Asians and other black and brown people say, our distorted stories will be told regardless of what we choose. A new Aladdin is currently in the works, where only a casting call has been announced as of yet. Guy Ritchie, the director of the live action adaption of the Disney film, is reportedly having a hard time finding a lead for the movie. Despite looking to South Asia and the Middle East for a potential lead—a massive improvement from casting, say, Jake Gyllenhaal—Ritchie is still unable to find a lead. They were slated to start shooting this month, but still have not had any luck.

While the prospect of having a person of color star in this film seems enticing, it really is not doing much for us. Aladdin strung together a few generalizations about North Africans, South East and South Asians, and blurred out our distinctions. The movie takes place in the fake city of Agrabah—combining together “Agra,” the historical city in northern India, with “Bah” to make it sound more Middle Eastern, I guess. The lack of specificity and care that went into the story is also the reason it doesn’t matter who the lead of this movie is, as long as he’s vaguely brown and maybe Muslim. The lack of investment in the actual history of our communities is reflected even today. It reflects the same imperialist logic that dictates, it doesn’t matter what the differences between them are, they’re all savages anyway.

Our people deserve better than these tired caricatures.

In order to have a movie that lets young Brown kids find value in our own cultures, instead of being reduced to two-dimensional versions of ourselves, we require specificity about our countries, cities, even the small hidden spaces of our communities. Equally importantly, these movies about us need to be made by us, and maybe if more were, we would have access to more lead actors who look like us, too.

Many pundits and writers have weighed in (though few brown ones) saying that we should be looking to Bollywood as an industry chock full of young brown men who can sing and dance. Bollywood solves no problems—the movie is inherently orientalist, and brown people endorsing and creating it just adds to the racism pitted against them.

Racism in the movie industry does not just happen one way, it is not just in the refusal to hire more actors of color. It also happens when a movie is made that has, for more than twenty years, been a symbol of the orientalism and racism faced by a number of communities in this country. So, kudos to Ritchie for waiting to start shooting until some brown dude is good enough to be in his movie, but that’s not the point.

An earlier version of this article incorrectly stated that a person of color would be shooting the film. This article has been corrected to reflect the identity of the director.



  1. AsianEastern on

    Originally, Aladdin was Chinese, and was sold by his parents to a middle eastern slave trader to the fictional city of Argrabah.

  2. Hi Fatima, I appreciate the argument that Disney’s previous interpretation of myth of Aladdin is problematic and contains troubling stereotypes, but considering the effort Disney’s put into its recent remakes to contain progressive themes and correct for the errors in its cartoons, why, if there’s no script or additional information on the film other than the casting call, is it automatically assumed this is going make the same mistakes? Additionally, I’d point out that the original myth of Aladdin is set in China and likely was first told In Syria, and first presented in English by a Frenchman, so the cultural appropriation, racist stereotypes (in the original myth about a Jewish merchant), and assumptions about a fictional Chinese city are deeply engrained into the myth itself – how should Disney correct for this in the film when the content itself is problematic, as most mythological tales are (like Zeus being both the god of all things and yet he rapes many people in Greek myths) – should western societies just not tell these stories?

    • Lmao exactly. Aladin was based in Middle East and was just a mythical story. While this Indian girl goes on whinging how she can’t find any of her cultural representations. If a white person had said so, he’d be accused of racism for conflating similar looking people but two different cultures. Moreover back in her India, they have plenty of rich cultural epics of their own. She wants USA to be the sole radio of everybody’s culture and mish mash & broadcast them for the whole world, to make her feel included here? What does anyone back in her country of origin, India know about intricacies of american culture? Nothing. We don’t whine about it, do we?

  3. It must be terribly exhausting and depressing to be so perpetually outraged and joyless about everything. It’s a freaking Disney cartoon with Robin Williams playing a genie. Why are you trying to rip apart your own childhood? This is sick and sad.

  4. I am of North African descent and I’m not brown. Why conflate everything with
    brown skin colour?? Can brown Spaniard join the club too? Can I be honorary brown? Actually no, I’m OK being human with whatever my skin colour is.

  5. Seems like everyone is hypersensitive to everything… Hyper-reactive. Seek serenity. Don’t overthink things, especially things created by people who are just trying to make kids happy with a tale and don’t really have a negative agenda attached to it. Live is much more easy to live if you just let some negativity roll under the bridge.

Leave A Reply